The Unrepentant Individual

...just hanging around until Dec 21, 2012

November 29, 2004

“Free” Health Care

The debate of government-provided health care raged throughout the campaign. Now, we don’t have to worry about Kerry being in office and pushing this on us, but judging from Bush’s history, I’m still a bit worried. Bush has not shown any real restraint in his spending during his first term, and his brand of “compassionate conservatism” seems to be a little too much Democrat-lite. I think he may take a few baby steps towards greater government control, so here’s why I think it’s a bad idea:

1) Health care is not a right

Rights are things that governments protect, not provide. People have only a right to freedom and to be left alone. The government involvement that best protects the rights of its citizens is to not get involved at all. When people make the argument that we have a fundamental “right” to health care, they forget about certain other people’s rights. Doctors, nurses, hospital administrators, and of course taxpayers. The reason that health care is not a right is that health care needs to be provided by someone. Whether that someone is a doctor, a spiritual healer, or the messiah, that someone cannot refuse to provide healthcare if it is a “right”. And once that doctor/etc is required to provide that care, he no longer has his rights protected. A system which arbitrarily subjugates one group’s rights (doctors who want to determine their own practice) to another (citizens who need health care) is inherently immoral. It doesn’t matter that the goal in mind, health care, is noble, if the method is immoral.

2) The government is not efficient

Do you want your doctor visits to most closely resemble the IRS, the DMV, or the post office? Our military, while the best in the world, isn’t exactly a shining model of efficiency. The rules behind something as simple as a tax code have been blasted beyond the point of comprehensibility. The IRS is supposed to offer competent tax advice, but they’re apparently wrong 50% of the time. The reason: there is no accountability. While private insurance is not incredibly efficient, it is driven by the need to adequately balance premiums and benefits. If they pay benefits too high without raising premiums, they go out of business. If they raise premiums without increasing service to create unreasonable profit, they lose business, and eventually will go out of business. There is a built-in corrective mechanism to ensure efficiency, which the government will never have as long as they are funded by taxes, which they can arbitrarily set or raise.

Likewise, if the government operates under the assumption that health care is a right, no burden should not be bared to cure or treat someone. I like to create a thought example. If, for example, I have a disease which will take a thousand dollars to cure, and I will die without a cure, should the government pay for it? Most people would say yes. After all, it is my right to be cured. Let’s say it is a hundred thousand dollars. Well, one can make the argument that spreading that over all the people in the US is not a major burden. How about a hundred million? Or a hundred billion? At some point, you reach a level where any reasonable person would admit that the burden on the rest of us is too high, and that I am not worth saving at that cost. In the market world, that limit is set by the market forces detailed above. Sometimes it’s not nice, but the system keeps working. In a government-run world, however, the government isn’t going to go bankrupt. The control on this sort of thing is absent.

3) Unpaid by the recipient is not “free”

I came across an article that I really liked. It compared health insurance to car insurance, and what would happen if car insurance covered things like oil changes and/or maintenance. Simply put, when something is provided to me at no cost, I am likely to use it as if it were free. Meaning that I am going to go to the doctor for something as simple as a cold, rather than waiting until it is serious. I am going to waste time and money on something that does not need attention, taking resources away from things that do. I will do this because I do not directly bear the “cost” of this attention. I personally believe that one of the factors leading to the increase in health care costs is the greater and greater role of insurance in the health care world. I am no longer required to make a choice between whether a service is needed, since I do not directly pay for it. As a result, I use unneeded services, making everyone else’s cost higher. That, spread over millions of people, raises the general cost of insurance drastically. If health insurance was more like car insurance, covering only the drastic and serious problems, we would all pay less. The more cost of health care that is felt directly by the consumer, the more market forces will self-improve the system and bring down overall costs.

4) There is no silver bullet

The number of drugs to treat problems is rising. The number of diseases that previously were deadly and are now treatable is growing. Life expectancy is increasing. Simply put, health care is becoming more expensive because it is continually getting better. And that is a good thing. Is there an easy answer to this question? Not at all. There are simple ways to improve or degrade the situation, but nothing is going to magically make health care cheap. I am currently sitting in Chicago for a major trade show about radiology. Companies are working their butts off to improve the ability to detect and treat diseases. The machines used are expensive and complex, and aren’t going to get cheaper. The only way to pay for this increased ability is by increasing cost, whether it be paid by consumers directly, insurance companies, or the government (of course, all three sources take their funds from individuals, in different ways). I would rather our health care can detect, treat, and cure more diseases, and if the cost of care rises to suit, so be it. It’s better than stagnation.

Over the course of the next few years, unfortunately I think greater government involvement is inevitable. I think that in the long term, it will lead to slower improvements in health care. Regardless of what system we use, the American people will perservere. But I believe that market-based health care will result in the strongest and fastest method for achieving improvements and better service. In the long term, if we can find cures (rather than treatments) for things like cancer, AIDS, diabetes, and a better understanding and treatment of the preconditions leading to heart disease, we will ultimately reduce the real cost of health care for most Americans. Preserving market-based health care will be the best way to see this day soon.

Posted By: Brad Warbiany @ 8:20 pm || Permalink || Comments (25) || Trackback URL || Categories: Uncategorized


  1. BW:
    Point 1 was an interesting arguement. Although I do beleive that soldiers are not provide the choice of which citizens they protect. Just as police officers are required to serve the entire community (whether or not this happens in reality is up for debate). Both of these professions offer “services” provided by the government. But interesting none the less.

    My real question is about part 3. I have also read an article comparing health and auto insurance. However in the article I read (perhaps it was the same) the point of the arguement was that our healthcare system needs to be revamped in order to get away from vastly growing costs. The arguement was, that if auto insurance was paid for by your employer (as many health insurances are) that you not only would feel free to take you car in whenever necessary, but you wouldn’t care what the auto shop was charging because at the end of the day you were dealing with only a small copay instead of the whole bill. This would lead to mechanics charging $100+ for an oil change and the individual consumers wouldn’t care. Of course we would all feel it in the end as the cost of insuring a car would sky rocket and those unemployed would find it very difficult to pay for it themselves.

    Sounds a bit like today’s health insurance situation…

    Comment by jrj — November 30, 2004 @ 5:18 pm
  2. BW1 here, long-time reader, first time poster…

    I would much rather comment on a post that I disagree with, but BW2 has certainly given this a lot of thought.
    No news to me, though, we have hashed this over many times.

    This was one of my major concerns about the recent election – Kerry’s desire to revamp the HC system with more goverment control.

    I think that BW1’s most poignant point was #2. The government is far from efficient and the most competitive, constructive situation is one that is privately held.

    Comment by Wilson — November 30, 2004 @ 6:28 pm
  3. JRJ,
    Good points on #1. I think that in some ways these arguments are based upon semantics, but at the same time it does bring up some good points. I can’t exactly refute it, but I can show that as “rights” are concerned, health care and safety from invaders or domestic violence are different.

    In the Declaration of Independence, it is stated that we have unalienable rights, among them life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness. Further, that governments job is to secure these rights, and that is the mandate upon which we give to government. From the declaration, they do say “among these” when referring to those above rights, so you could make a claim that health care (or anything else) is a right. But since the declaration is not a binding document legally, we have to defer to the Constitution. In the constitution (art I, sec 8, enumeration of powers), it is clearly stated that the government shall have the power to raise armies. Most police forces are state or local, so they do not fall under the federal purview.

    I agree that the argument can be made that if government provides an army and police force to provide for our rights, why should health care be different? But I think that there are differences between the nature of these two rights, both in a logical sense and a legal sense. From a legal standpoint, the Constitution will need to be amended for the federal government to be involved (not like they’ve ever listened to that).

    Comment by Brad Warbiany — December 1, 2004 @ 6:00 am
  4. Your have a great blog. I enjoy reading the stories on your site. I have my own blog aboutcheap auto insurance check out my site aboutcheap auto insurance .

    Comment by Jacson Normant — September 30, 2005 @ 7:46 pm
  5. Hi, I was looking around some blogger blogs for some ideas to start my own on ebooks and you have given me some great ideas. Good blog. I will check it out every week. Thanks

    Comment by Quit Smoking — October 3, 2005 @ 7:23 pm
  6. You keep a nice blog. I just started one myself, about Diseases. If you know of anyone who’d benefit from Diseases information, then please refer them to my Diseases information site. I’ll return the favor.

    Let’s put an end to the suffering.
    Find A Cure For Any Disease!

    Comment by Disease Index — October 4, 2005 @ 3:30 pm
  7. You keep a very nice blog. I’m new to the whole blog thingy, but I enjoy reading through other people’s blogs.
    Let’s end the suffering of all Diseases
    Find A Cure For Any Disease:

    Comment by Disease Index — October 4, 2005 @ 7:23 pm
  8. We had been blogging trying to find how our world sees womens health
    . It has been a lifeline for us. Your site provides some of the best examples of this sort and we will bookmark yours. Another one we found was and appears to be related to yours is womens health
    site/blog. It pretty much covers womens health
    related stuff.

    Comment by Tom Naka — October 8, 2005 @ 11:21 am
  9. Nice blog! I have a lead free wave solder site I thought you and your visitors might like.

    Click on lead free wave solder to check it out. lead free wave solder

    Comment by Danny White — October 20, 2005 @ 5:09 pm
  10. San Diego is having a Hot Rod Halloween on Sunday, October 30. If you love grand theft auto san andreas then you will want to be there! All kinds of grand theft auto san andreas will be in attendance. For more information go to grand theft auto san andreas
    See Ya There!!

    Comment by Anonymous — October 23, 2005 @ 2:26 am
  11. Cars at their best corvette locator

    Comment by Anonymous — October 23, 2005 @ 6:57 pm
  12. I just came across your blog, and wanted to drop you a note telling you how impressed I was with the information you have posted here. I also have a american family insurance blog, so I know what I’m talking about when I say your site is top-notch! Keep up the great work, you are providing a great resource on the Internet here!

    Comment by . — October 27, 2005 @ 11:26 am
  13. I have a related california health insurance plan blog you might want to check out

    Comment by Anonymous — October 27, 2005 @ 12:50 pm
  14. I Really think you have a great blog here.

    I have several pages of my own:

    My first blog/site is about cheap car insurance rate and covers cheap car insurance rate related stuff.
    My Second blog/site is about Work From Home..
    My Third blog/site is about Wheel Chairs and covers Wheel Chairs related stuff.

    Please feel free to visit.

    Comment by Car Insurance Center — October 30, 2005 @ 8:27 pm
  15. Great blog post.

    I thought your readers would like to see this site as well:
    aa car insurance quote or check out for aa car insurance quote info.

    Comment by Anonymous — November 1, 2005 @ 9:59 pm
  16. Now here is a site that has put all the health resources under one hat. Just go an see.**Ju Health** Their webmaster has also gone through some trouble finding interested and health related article. I signed up for their newsletter **Health and Wellness in the 21st Century** and you may want to do so as well since their newsletter person will covering “the baseline of health”. So far the topics covered have been pretty interesting. I can’t wait to read what they have to say about detoxification of the body. You are even allowed to submit your own article.

    Comment by Jaynne — November 2, 2005 @ 7:34 pm
  17. A

    Comment by home equity line of credit — November 28, 2005 @ 5:11 pm
  18. Hey this blog is not about low cost home owners insurance. Silly internet bringing me here :-) Funny I have been doing hours of research on low cost home owners insurance and it brought me to your blog on this post. The web plays funny games sometimes. Anyways, I was reading your blog Brad and I think it is really cool. Keep up the great work.
    If you do not mind I will snag your blog and put it in my favorites. I read a ton of stuff on here that interested me. Keep blogging away :-)

    Comment by home renters insurance — December 12, 2005 @ 5:37 am
  19. Hey Brad. Very nice blog :0) I just got inside from washing and waxing my truck. It is my baby. Took me 2 hours though. So I settled down into my basement and started doing some web surfing. Anyways I am in the process of grabbing my masters degree and have spent the last 6 months researching home renters insurance. In the midst of my surfing I landed smack dab in the middle of your blog. I hope you do not think I am intruding but I must say it is great blog. Even though this post is way off base from home renters insurance I found myself cruising through your blog archives for the last half hour :0) You have some nice blogging friends. Anyways, I need to get back to my mission. I wrote don’t your url and feel free to visit me here at home renters insurance. I am so busy so I can only update my site monthly. Keep up the great work.

    Comment by home renters insurance — December 12, 2005 @ 8:59 pm
  20. I have been on-line searching for hours for information regarding chicago building home insurances and stumbled across your blog during my journey :-) Brad your blog is really amazing! Keep up the great work. Obviously my search on chicago building home insurances was way off when compared to this post and find it funny how it landed me here. The internet is a funny thing. Anyways, great job on your blogging and keep up the good work! I been searching for chicago building home insurances for over 2 hours and needed a break from it. I started reading your blog and really started getting into it.
    P.S I will add you to my favorites so I can come back and visit later
    P.S.S If you want to bookmark my site I am at chicago building home insurances. You never know you may find some good deals!

    Comment by travelers home insurances — December 14, 2005 @ 7:15 am
  21. Well this blog certainly is not about las vegas home insurances. What the heck! I guess the internet can play some tricks on us sometimes. I have been on-line for two hours
    researching las vegas home insurances and came tumbling across your blog. I LOVE IT! I needed a break from las vegas home insurances anyways :-) If you don’t mind I want to add your
    blog to my favorites list so I can come back later on and read some more stuff. Well I guess I should get back to researching las vegas home insurances.
    Even though my search is not on this post I am glad I came across your blog. Keep blogging away!

    Comment by california home insurances — December 14, 2005 @ 6:33 pm
  22. All I can say is WOW Brad. The other half and I just got back from our friends house (well her friends house) and I needed a huge break. I am working on a project right now that is based on las vegas home insurances. I have literally been on-line for 2-3 hours doing research. Even though this post really isn’t on the same page as las vegas home insurances I am certainly glad I came across your blog. There are a ton of great view points on this blog. Well I think I can here the kids screaming in the background. I put you in my internet favorites and I will certainly come back and visit. If you want to take a peek at my site you can find me here at las vegas home insurances. I update my site very frequently. Again, great job blogging and I will be back again soon!

    Comment by portland oregon home insurances — December 15, 2005 @ 5:52 am
  23. Hey this blog is not about best home insurances. Silly internet bringing me here :-) Funny I have been doing hours of research on best home insurances and it brought me to your blog on this post. The web plays funny games sometimes. Anyways, I was reading your blog Brad and I think it is really cool. Keep up the great work.
    If you do not mind I will snag your blog and put it in my favorites. I read a ton of stuff on here that interested me. Keep blogging away :-)

    Comment by home title insurances — December 17, 2005 @ 7:47 am
  24. Hi Brad your blog is really great! Wow :-) As I was out blog surfing and surfing the web for detailed info on home renters insurance I stumbled across your blog. Obviously my search landed me here and it is a little off subject compared to this post, but I am certainly glad I did come across your blog. Did I already tell you I like it! If you would not mind, I would like to add your link to my “favorites” page to come back and read again sometime. Should you ever need it, there’s lots of information on this site about home renters insurance. Again, great blog and keep up the great work!

    Comment by chicago building home insurances — December 18, 2005 @ 5:09 pm
  25. I love your blog, I’ve found another cool site auto by tel

    Comment by insurance quotes car — January 10, 2006 @ 8:31 am

RSS feed for comments on this post.

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.