The Unrepentant Individual

...just hanging around until Dec 21, 2012

September 28, 2005

Congress tackles performance-enhancing drugs in music

As part of their ongoing hearings about performance-enhancing drugs in the music industry, RIAA Chairman and CEO Mitch Bainwol faced a Congressional panel today. At issue was the growing inability of the major recording labels to rein in artists who were known for using dangerous narcotics known for helping musicians create great music.

Before the panel, Bainwol said “It is the position of the RIAA that performance-enhancing drugs like heroin, marijuana and LSD should not be a part of the recording industry. Efforts are being made to educate artists about the dangers of such drugs, but have not had the intended effect. At this time we are wary of mandatory testing, however, as it might drive the best artists into small, independent labels where oversight is even less aggressive.”

Congress has been increasingly concerned about the use of dangerous narcotics in the music industry. Many popular artists are seen as role models for their young, impressionable fans. But the recent discovery of classical cellist Yo-Yo Ma’s $2000/day cocaine habit shocked everyone. According to Senator Jim Bunning, “When respectable classical musicians such as Yo-Yo are found to be enhancing their performance with the ‘caine, it shows that this problem is so much deeper than we had once thought. Congress must act quickly to restore the public’s faith in the music industry.”

Even more troublesome is the pressure on other artists when they see the success of their dope-fueled contemporaries. William Shatner, in an interview at a recent Star Trek convention, said “I’ve never used any illegal drugs to enhance my albums, and I think that shows in their quality.” He did not realize the irony of his comments, as many drug users credit hearing Shatner’s “spoken word” albums as creating the impetus within them to start using drugs in the first place.

This sentiment was echoed by rocker Courtney Love, known for her battles with the ’sound potion’, heroin. “I’ve been clean for a whole two years now. [My] last album? It didn’t go platinum. Hell, I don’t think it even went aluminum! If my dealer hadn’t [been] locked up a few months ago, I would have started using drugs again. I need some royalty [money], or my baby is gonna starve!”

Of greater importance is the danger of these drugs. Many talented musicians, from Elvis Presley, to Jim Morrison, Jazz legend Charlie Parker, even country star Hank Williams, have paid the ultimate price for their success. Senator John McCain elaborated, “What message does it send to our kids that they need to risk the penalty of death just to succeed in the music industry? How can we allow a system that absolutely requires aspiring musicians to take dangerous, mind-bending drugs, risking their own lives, just for a slice of fame?”

The correlation between drug use and musical success is hard to prove. After all, it is not clear whether the great musicians were great before their drug use. But the experience of Scott Weiland, former frontman of Stone Temple Pilots, has shown strong evidence of a causative relationship. During the times when Weiland was in the throes of heroin addiction, his music inspired listeners and pleased critics with its depth and sense of purpose. While he was clean, however, his music suffered, with fans, critics, and on the Billboard charts.

Congress’ action brings up certain major questions. Since it will not affect Canadian musicians, it may result in the increasing popularization of Canadian artists. Considering their strange accents and tendency to say “aboot” rather than “about”, that cannot be a good thing for music in general.

Even more important is the role of Congress in the regulation of the music industry. Musicians contend that hampering their ‘personal habits’ will only cause music in general to suffer. And the RIAA is feeling their turf infringed, as the Congress is stepping in to handle problems they cannot control on their own. But to Senator’s McCain and Bunning, where the market has failed, the Congress must act:

McCain and Bunning said they’d prefer not to legislate but warned that Congress is prepared to.

“For whatever reason, you just can’t get it done, and you can’t get your act together,” Bunning said. “I and millions of fans think that’s pathetic.”

The Owner's Manual linked with #106 Best of Me Symphony
Eric's Grumbles Before The Grave linked with Carnival of Liberty XIV
Posted By: Brad Warbiany @ 6:07 pm || Permalink || Comments (6) || Trackback URL || Categories: Uncategorized


  1. I hate to admit this, but Eric Clapton’s musical creativity while he was strung out on heroin was extraordinary. His greatest albums were made while he was a junkie. Since getting clean, his music has become sanitized, less-daring, and far less great. Of course, he’s still with us, which most likely would not be true if he had continued to use at the rate he was using. But there’s no doubt his musical creativity is not what it once was.

    Comment by Arizona Lawyer — September 29, 2005 @ 1:10 pm
  2. YoYo Ma? Are you sure? You just crushed my image of the man. I love his work.

    Comment by Lucy Stern — September 29, 2005 @ 2:05 pm
  3. Never forget the masterful work of David Peel, the Yippie who spent decades in the East Village of NYC.
    Warbling his immortal–if somewhat repetitive– tone poem “Marijuana” and strumming 1 or 2 guitar chords
    as effortlessly as a bird flies. Though some claimed he seemed as burnt out as an old bong, those
    with deeper insight realized he’d attained the kind of artistic greatness only drugs can produce.

    Carola at Mondo QT

    Comment by Carola Solomonoff — September 29, 2005 @ 7:10 pm
  4. It’s satire. I believe he chose Yo-yo Ma because it’s obvious the guy would never do drugs.

    Comment by Ferdinand T. Cat — October 2, 2005 @ 4:16 pm
  5. Carnival of Liberty XIV

    Welcome to Carnival of Liberty XIV. We’ve got a great Carnival going this week, although there was not really enough for anyone to comment on Roberts’ confirmation as Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, or the nomination of Harriet Miers…

    Trackback by Eric's Grumbles Before The Grave — October 4, 2005 @ 8:59 am
  6. #106 Best of Me Symphony

    Zendo Deb asks if we are beginning to recognize that a Restraining Order’s Just a Piece of Paper. From TFS Magnum. Success is relative. It is what we can make of the mess we have made of things. Only

    Trackback by The Owner's Manual — December 5, 2005 @ 12:07 am

RSS feed for comments on this post.

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.