The Unrepentant Individual

...just hanging around until Dec 21, 2012

April 14, 2007

Book Review — Mean Martin Manning, by Scott Stein

Some of you have probably notice me link the Scott Stein a few times in the past. I found him a while back, when he was looking for examples of humorous writing for a class he was teaching. In fact, I even got him to give me a literary critique of The Search For The Beast, which was quite helpful, and I hope to incorporate into future writing.

So I decided to pick up his new book, Mean Martin Manning. I actually paid for it, because his publisher apparently doesn’t give review copies to unknown bloggers with limited readership, but that’s alright, it was worth it (partly because it comes with little “extras” in the package, which is nice).

The book is a novel describing an exciting episode the normally uneventful life of Martin Manning, an elderly man who has spent 30 years shut off from the world. Surviving on cold-cuts, television, a collection of clocks and porcelain frogs, and ordering everything he needs from the internet, he’s quite happy to live without any human interaction whatsoever. But one day, in order to comply with a new government “Life Improvement” program, social worker Alice Pitney shows up. And all hell breaks loose.

Armed with the full force and power of the state government, Pitney is determined to help a man who wants no help. He’s forced into the improvement program, where he’s expected to eat healthy foods, interact with all sorts of crazy characters, and the self-sufficient shut-in is treated like a child to be trained in how to be a better person. In his first group therapy session, Manning says it best:

“You poor saps can go for Pitney’s bullshit if you like— I won’t hold it against you. I just want to give you fair warning. It might not look like it, but as we speak, I’m in an epic struggle with Caseworker Pitney for my very soul.”

Immovable force meets a nanny-statist who won’t take no for an answer, and all sorts of hilarity ensues. Oh, did I mention that Stein is funny? This book doesn’t read like Atlas Shrugged, it pops with it’s collection of smart-assed narration and just-cartoonish-enough characters. The book has an air of the fantastic about it, but then again, when you hear about some of the things going on in Britain, it almost seems like it will be here shortly.

As for the politics, I can’t see many libertarians not liking the book, or not cheering on Martin Manning as he fights against those who want to control him for his own good. It gives a face and a name to the insidious nature of the nanny state. It reminds you that you should stand extra guard when they try to come after you for your own good, as C.S. Lewis once said:

Of all tyrannies, a tyranny exercised for the good of its victims may be the most oppressive. It may be better to live under robber barons than under omnipotent moral busybodies. The robber baron’s cruelty may sometimes sleep, his cupidity may at some point be satiated; but those who torment us for our own good will torment us without end, for they do so with the approval of their own conscience.

Overall, the book gets a hearty recommendation. It clicks in at just over 200 pages, so it’s a quick read, but long enough to develop the characters, put together a cohesive plot, and make it all interesting. As for distribution, I think you may need to go to the publisher directly on this one, though, unfortunately it’s not up on Amazon. Either way, check it out.

the Scott Stein linked with A few good men ... and women
the Scott Stein linked with Response to a review
Atlas Blogged linked with Mean Martin Manning
Posted By: Brad Warbiany @ 10:17 pm || Permalink || Comments (4) || Trackback URL || Categories: Books, Libertarianism


  1. I’ve been meaning to read this. I’ve been meaning to drum up a little more attention for him, too – I think his use of blogs for his characters is GREAT.

    Hopefully I can turn “meaning to” into action.

    Comment by Wulf — April 17, 2007 @ 7:32 pm
  2. Mean Martin Manning

    I have neglected this topic for far too long. I have ordered my copy of Mean Martin Manning by the Scott Stein. Now, I am a fairly busy guy. I don’t have as much time to read these days…

    Trackback by Atlas Blogged — April 19, 2007 @ 9:40 pm
  3. Response to a review

    The Philadelphia Inquirer reviews Mean Martin Manning today. I’d characterize the review as, at best, lukewarm — that is, the reviewer did say that he enjoyed it, but also had a few quibbles with the novel and didn’t have the…

    Trackback by the Scott Stein — April 22, 2007 @ 7:56 am
  4. A few good men … and women

    Thank you to bloggers Brad Warbiany and Wulf at Atlas Blogged…

    Trackback by the Scott Stein — April 22, 2007 @ 9:50 pm

RSS feed for comments on this post.

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.